Benny Carter & Oscar Peterson – Benny Carter Meets Oscar Peterson

Two names above a quintet

Benny Carter Meets Oscar Peterson names a partnership, but five musicians make the record. On 14 November 1986, Carter and Peterson were joined in Los Angeles by Joe Pass on guitar, Dave Young on bass and Martin Drew on drums, with Norman Granz producing. Carter was 79. His musical connection with Peterson already extended back several decades.

The pair had worked together on Alone Together in 1952. “Meets” therefore does not describe a first introduction. It brings two long careers into focus at a later shared moment. Remembering the quintet behind the title also opens the album beyond its two leading names: each of the other musicians has a role in shaping how the performances unfold.

Familiar songs and a shared composition

Six standards lead to “Some Kind of Blues”, jointly credited to Carter and Peterson. The programme includes “Just Friends”, “Sweet Lorraine”, “Baubles, Bangles and Beads”, “It’s a Wonderful World”, “If I Had You” and “Whisperin’”. Familiar material supplies a common starting point without determining every choice the players will make.

If you already know a melody, listen for the timing of a phrase and the response around it. A pause or a change in emphasis becomes easier to follow when the song itself is recognisable. The closing blues places a composition shared by the two leaders alongside those established standards, offering another perspective on their meeting.

Give the guitar its own hearing

Piano and guitar have overlapping possibilities within a small group: both can state harmony, reinforce rhythm or carry an independent line. Pass is central to that balance. Following his part for one passage and Peterson’s for another can reveal how the ensemble works around Carter’s alto saxophone.

Young and Drew add another route into the performance. Notice the joins between phrases and between soloists: who responds to a closing statement, and who prepares the next entrance? Those questions do not require a technical analysis. They simply shift attention from an isolated solo to the musicians making it possible. The repertoire gives everyone a shared language, while the particular combination of players makes this session its own event.

The Analogue Productions Pablo edition

AAPJ 192 is a single 180-gram LP playing at 33⅓ RPM. Matthew Lutthans mastered it at The Mastering Lab from the original analogue master tape, according to the publisher. Pressing is by Quality Record Pressings. The seven selections preserve the 1986 quintet session: two celebrated names on the sleeve, with five musicians responsible for the music.

Michael 45 keeps the goods in Germany and dispatches from Hilden, so customers in Germany and across the EU can order without arranging a personal US import or facing the associated customs wait.

More from the series: Analogue Productions (Pablo)

Customer question: Buying Analogue Productions records in Europe

Series: Pablo – all 30 records, musicians and the session book

Musicians

Documented selection of participating musicians. Personnel may vary by track; this list does not claim to be complete.