SACD Charles Mingus – Blues & Roots

The blues as the beginning of a larger musical world

On Blues & Roots, Charles Mingus accepts an apparently straightforward challenge: to make an album placing his music in a clear relationship with the blues. Producer Nesuhi Ertegun had encouraged the project. For Mingus, however, a return to roots does not mean confinement to one form or mood. These six compositions can press forward collectively, isolate an individual voice, work through repetition or set several lines against one another. The blues becomes a starting point from which a whole musical environment can be explored.

The recordings are made in New York on 4 February 1959. Nesuhi Ertegun produces, Tom Dowd is credited as engineer, and Atlantic releases the album in 1960. Mingus plays double bass, writes every composition and leads an unusually colourful ensemble. Two alto saxophones, tenor, baritone and two trombones meet piano, bass and drums. That makes nine simultaneous instrumental positions, with a change of pianist within the programme. Ten musicians participate in total, without the group becoming a ten-piece ensemble throughout the recording.

The distinction suits music whose character emerges from the interaction of separate voices. The horns do not merely combine into an anonymous wall. Different registers, attacks and personalities can support one another or create friction. Mingus does not require a trumpet for this setting: all six horn chairs are occupied by saxophones and trombones. That particular mixture gives the album an instrumental identity of its own. Following which voice takes up a figure and which answers it provides a direct route into the arrangements, without needing to begin with a technical explanation of every passage.

Prayer Meeting, Moanin’ and the ensemble’s voices

Wednesday Night Prayer Meeting opens with a title that already points towards a communal form of musical expression. Listen for the relationship between recurring figures and individual interjections. Mingus does not think exclusively in terms of theme, solo and the next solo. The ensemble itself can become an active counterpart. Cryin’ Blues then brings another balance within the same broad subject. These two consecutive selections give the opening a clearly defined shape before the programme moves towards its third piece.

Moanin’ follows as the third selection. This is Mingus’ composition, distinct from Bobby Timmons’ piece of the same name. Pepper Adams’ baritone saxophone is an important reference point for the colour of this performance. Its low register differs markedly from the two altos and Booker Ervin’s tenor. The distinction concerns more than pitch: the attack of a phrase and the weight given to a recurring figure contribute to the character as well. The larger ensemble consequently offers more than the possibility of additional volume or a thicker background behind the soloists.

Tensions and My Jelly Roll Soul follow as tracks four and five, suggesting different directions even in the juxtaposition of their titles. E’s Flat Ah’s Flat Too completes the programme as track six. Every composition is by Mingus, yet the material does not ask the band to maintain one unchanging attitude. For collectors who know the composer through other recordings, this is particularly rewarding. Blues & Roots illuminates a specific part of his musical world without pretending to offer a complete explanation of everything he wrote or played.

Ten names, nine chairs and an important change of pianist

The two alto saxophonists are John Handy and Jackie McLean. Booker Ervin plays tenor, Pepper Adams baritone, while Jimmy Knepper and Willie Dennis occupy the trombone chairs. With Mingus on bass and Dannie Richmond on drums, the ensemble brings together registers that deserve to be identified accurately. An alto is not simply a tenor with a different label, and the baritone does not merely duplicate a part an octave below. The individual voices form part of the compositional resources on which the album draws.

Horace Parlan plays piano on the first five selections: Wednesday Night Prayer Meeting, Cryin’ Blues, Moanin’, Tensions and My Jelly Roll Soul. Mal Waldron appears only on E’s Flat Ah’s Flat Too. They should therefore not be presented as two pianists playing together across the entire record. This single change also explains why a complete personnel list contains ten names. The credits for this edition retain the relationship to individual tracks instead of losing it in an undifferentiated album-wide entry.

Richmond and Mingus connect the horns to a responsive rhythmic foundation. A rewarding approach is to move your attention temporarily away from the prominent horn voices towards bass and drums. What holds a recurring figure together, and what gives an entrance renewed energy? Returning to the different registers afterwards can reveal another aspect of their interaction. Such changes of focus make repeated listening productive. There is no need to reduce the record to one famous number or to analyse every instant. Knowing the personnel provides orientation while leaving the music’s immediate force intact.

Atlantic 75 on hybrid SACD

This edition is CAPA 001 SA, part of the Analogue Productions Atlantic 75 Series. It presents the complete six-selection album in stereo on hybrid SACD. Kevin Gray at Cohearent Audio is responsible for mastering; the publisher describes a transfer from the original analogue tape directly to DSD. That source statement belongs to this particular release. It is not expanded here into an unsupported claim about DSD sampling rate or combined with specifications belonging to a vinyl pressing. The disc is a distinct edition alongside the separately available 45 RPM double LP.

Hybrid construction provides a CD-compatible layer in addition to the SACD layer. An appropriate SACD player can access the SACD layer, while a conventional CD player can play the CD layer. This is a practical consideration for an existing system, rather than a reason to make a blanket comparison between formats. The programme runs in album order from Wednesday Night Prayer Meeting to E’s Flat Ah’s Flat Too, without the interruptions required by a four-sided vinyl presentation. Track references in the personnel list consequently refer to these six selections, not to record sides.

The presentation uses a Super Jewel Box. The documented edition entry identifies Sonopress as manufacturer and Sony DADC for glass mastering; those manufacturing credits do not establish additional facts about the musical transfer. The useful selection criteria here are the identified mastering, the stereo programme and the hybrid format. Listeners wishing to follow Mingus’ interplay of composed figures and responsive individual voices through a complete album pass have all six pieces in their regular sequence. The final change from Parlan to Waldron remains a small but revealing detail within a connected musical idea.

This gives the release a precise place in a Mingus collection: the same historical recording, a specifically documented digital edition and complete personnel rather than a shortlist of the most famous names. Knowing who plays, and where, helps connect the packaging to the performances without prescribing how the record must be heard. You order from Michael 45 in Germany. We arrange the US import and dispatch from Hilden.

Also in another edition: Blues & Roots

More by Charles Mingus: Mingus, Mingus, Mingus, Mingus, Mingus · The Clown

Customer question: Buying Analogue Productions records in Europe

Musicians

Participants and documented credit status. Track references correspond to the tracklist.

• Charles Mingusdouble bass, composition, bandleaderParticipation: alle 6
• Dannie RichmonddrumsParticipation: alle 6
• John Handyalto saxophoneParticipation: alle 6
• Jackie McLeanalto saxophoneParticipation: alle 6
• Booker Ervintenor saxophoneParticipation: alle 6
• Pepper Adamsbaritone saxophoneParticipation: alle 6
• Jimmy KneppertromboneParticipation: alle 6
• Willie DennistromboneParticipation: alle 6
• Horace ParlanpianoParticipation: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
• Mal WaldronpianoParticipation: 6

Track numbers and side references correspond to this edition. Album credits do not mean every instrument appears on every track.